Preached at 2007 Toronto Conference Ethnic Rally at Toronto Chinese United Church
by the Rev. Richard C. Choe
Stretching to the fullest.
A few years ago I went back to South Korea to visit and I toured an old prison in Seoul. It had been turned into a walk through museum. In the basement of the jail, I saw small prison cells no bigger than a broom closet. They were purposely designed with very low ceilings so the prisoners could only stand with their necks bent. Can you imagine never being allowed to stand fully erect? My neck hurts as I think about it now. The effect of such prison cells was to break prisoners’ spirits as well as their bodies.
The prison was built and used during the Japanese military occupation of Korea from 1909 to 1945. The jail is now a museum so visitors can see and experience the shameful period of Korean history when the Japanese Military Regime ruled Korea with brutality and violence until the Atom bombs were dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945.
The prison cell in South Korea reminds me of Luke’s story of a bent woman with a spirit that had crippled her for 18 years. Not being able to stretch to her full height must have been torturous. Only seeing the ground she was walking on – littered with things people would carefully avoid stepping on. Never being able to look people in the eye. But the worst part of it all must have been the inability to stretch to the fullest of her being.
An unnamed, bent over woman encounters Jesus one Sabbath Day and was set free from her ailment and was able to stand straight and praise God for letting her be able to stretch to her full height. But the religious authority can only focus on the fact that Jesus transgressed the rules of the Sabbath.
In the time of Jesus, physical difference was accepted as a curse, a sign of an individual’s sin or the sins of one’s ancestors. Having any physical contact with such a person also placed one at the risk of being cursed as well. It was not just during the time of Jesus that physical difference was seen as a curse. It continues to happen in our time.
Societies continue to define and dictate what is acceptable and “normative” to the public. Media spins the “orthodoxy” – “belief in or agreement with what is, or is currently held to be right, especially in religious matters.”[i] And the public continues to perpetuate the orthodoxy until a brave soul, like Jesus, stands tall and challenges public opinion.
Tracy Turnblad is a generously portioned high school student in Baltimore, Maryland in 1962. The highlight of her day is to watch The Corny Collins Show, a local teen dance show from Station WYZT, with her friend, Penny Pingleton.
When the Station is looking for a new dancer for The Corny Collins Show, Tracy auditions for the show but gets turned away for being overweight and supportive of racial integration of the show.
This is 1962 in Baltimore. Only once a month are African American kids allowed to be part of The Corny Collins Show. Racism was in full swing.
Besides catchy tunes and wonderful dance moves, the play and the movie Hairspray shows how the United States struggled with the issues of race, intertwined with socio-political disparities, in the 1960s. The physical standards – physical preferences of the media, to be precise – based on people’s sizes, both height and width, along with the colour of one’s skin is also at a forefront of the issues the movie deals with. Parts of the movie were captured in Toronto so there are familiar landmarks as people march along the Roncesvalles Village near High Park.
When Black and White young people fall in love with one another – like the characters of Seaweed and Penny – and people finally stand up for their rights – the way African Americans and Tracy and her Mom march for racial integration of the dance show – the walls of segregation begin to tumble down. When people begin to lift their heads and reach to their full potential, equal rights, and privileges, communities begin to experience healing and freedom.
It was not just African Americans who were healed by marching toward healing and freedom when they stood up for their God-given inalienable rights to be equal with their White neighbours. The rest of American society – First Nations Peoples, Whites, Asians, and bi- and multi- racial people of all shades began to be healed and freed in the process. By segregating one segment of society, those who were enforcing segregation were also in need of healing and freedom from their racism and hatred of their neighbours. Canada was not exempt.
It is amazing how the church and societies do not seem to realise that the disease of discrimination against the downtrodden and minorities of any community always points to the illness of the majority of the members within it. There is much resistance toward the healing of the community and the Other just the way the bent woman’s community seemed unwilling to heal her themselves, and heal themselves in the process.
The Very Rev. Dr. Bill Phipps, who served as the Moderator of The United Church of Canada from 1997 to 2000, speaks of the necessary transformation of humanity as a process of moving away from being co-opted and perpetuating the Old Story – stories that are characterized by violence, fear, domination, arrogance, and competition. In his new book Cause for Hope: Humanity as the Crossroads,[ii] he speaks of moving to the New Story – stories that are characterized by mutual respect, cooperation, laughter, humility, interdependence, interconnection, and gratitude. When you change the story, you can change the context of your life and the future.
Much of our Church, The United Church of Canada, still believes, participates, perpetuates, and disseminates the Old Story. When the Ethnic Ministries Council was being developed as a way of transforming the United Church in 1992, many in the church raised questions about creating a national program unit that would “isolate and segregate” ethnic minorities from the rest of the church. What they have not asked themselves was the question why they, the dominant part of church, have been “isolating and segregating” the ethnic minorities since the inception of the United Church. There were no visible minority or First Nations Commissioners at the Mutual Arena celebrating the inception of The United Church of Canada in 1925.
The same question continues even today, eleven years after the creation of the Ethnic Ministries Council. Like the religious authority in the Luke story, the people of the status quo can only focus on the fact that ethnic minorities are doing something that is contrary to the rules and regulations that have benefited them to remain dominant within the church.
“Why Ethnic Ministries Council/Unit?” Many of us who have been part of the Ethnic Ministries Council/Unit have been answering this question for more than seventeen years.
The institutional racism within The United Church of Canada has segregated and isolated ethnic minorities as the Other within the Church from the time of Union in 1925. It is questionable whether the founding vision of the United Church of being One in Christ Jesus had any intention to include anyone other than White Europeans.
Being One in the United Church for many ethnic minorities, Peoples of the First Nations, and French Canadians has been and still is about being assimilated into White Anglo Saxon Protestant values that have too often been expressed as the Old Story of alienation, belittlement and exclusion of ethnic minorities in the church. What we seek through the leadership of Ethnic Ministries is integration of the whole where each part of Christ’ body is valued and appreciated and is part of transforming the whole.
So when ethnic minorities within the Church, in partnership with some ethnic majority allies, spoke for establishing a national unit that would encourage, enable, and empower ethnic minorities along with the rest of the Church, those of the Old Story saw it as a threat to their status quo rather than a gift to the Church.
Ethnic Ministries, Aboriginal Ministries, and French Ministries have a vision to begin to tell the New Story of the United Church – stories that are based on mutual and interconnected relationships amongst all peoples within and outside the Church.
But when you are only used to the Old Story – a paradigm of competition, and divide and conquer – ways of interdependence by establishing, developing and nurturing all parts of the Body of Jesus Christ can only be seen as “isolation and segregation” of the minorities.
The proposal from the Ethnic Ministries Unit for the United Church to embrace intercultural ministry – a ministry of mutuality between and amongst all racial/ethnic/cultural communities – and to become an intercultural church was accepted at the 39th General Council of The United Church of Canada in Thunder Bay in 2006. The church committed itself to move toward the New Story for the common good of all.
The United Church needs intercultural ministry – a ministry between and among peoples of various racial/ethnic communities – a ministry that envisions, pursues, and lives out the original vision of Jesus Christ “That All May be One.” What we need is individual and corporate courage to live the New Story of interrelatedness, mutuality, and interdependence where no one is left out and where everyone is truly appreciated and valued as children of God.
The intercultural church we envision is about faith communities that seek partnership amongst the disenfranchised to enable and empower themselves to be equal partners in the ministry of Jesus Christ. It is about inviting and challenging those who are in the status quo to courageously “de-centre” themselves to join the community where everyone is truly equal as servants of the ministry of Jesus Christ. It is about re-membering – as in re-connecting – our church to find ways to establish right relationship with sisters and brothers in First Nations communities and with one another.
My hope is that the intercultural vision would provide a thorough understanding of the Old Story in order to not keep repeating the old paradigms of empowerment of some at the disempowerment and dispossession of others. James Cone cautions us that “lack of knowledge of one’s past leads inevitably to self-hatred and self-hate leads one to love the oppressor’s values, and thus to act against one’s own freedom.”[iii] Ethnic minorities in the church would need to unlearn the behaviour of being Native Informers – those who have been co-opted to the Old Story that they have internalized the racist values of their oppressors deeply within them. Ethnic majorities in the church, on the other hand, would need to embrace and accept who they are without the trappings of the unearned privileges and status of being White in Canada. What we are envisioning together as ethnic minorities and ethnic majorities through intercultural ministry is a faith community that tells the New Story that heals and transforms all within it.
An Intercultural church should be a place where faith and life stories of each one in the community is lifted up and cherished so we can all live to our fullest. It is a community where the Journeys of Black Peoples is a healing and peace-making journey of peoples of all African descents. It is a community where the Sounding the Bamboo is a healing and life transforming event for racial ethnic minority women. It is also a community where people of the land and people from away; where men, women, youth, children, gays, lesbian, transgendered, and differently abled folks are all welcomed and embraced as sisters and brothers in God’s love.
Intercultural Church is a vision of a community where the last, the least and the lost in our society are invited and welcomed as part of our community. Intercultural church is not a middle class ghetto where only upwardly mobile folks from various racial-ethnic cultural communities congregate for the next opportunity to advance themselves by peddling the “hierarchy of pain” through which one community’s Otherness becomes a ticket for one’s personal and individual success. Intercultural church is where everyday is “intercultural day” and every aspect of ministry and worship is intercultural in ethos and in practice.
There is a song in the movie Hairspray that says a lot about our communal journey in intercultural ministry. The civil rights marchers sing “I Know Where I’ve Been” as they demonstrate for the de-segregation of the dance show.
Motormouth Maybelle Stubbs, played by Queen Latifah, leads the singing as they march for freedom and the healing of society.“There's a dreamIn the futureThere's a struggleWe have yet to winAnd there's prideIn my heart 'Cause I knowWhere I'm goingAnd I know where I've beenIn my heart 'Cause I knowWhere I'm goingAnd I know where I've beenThere's a roadWe must travelThere's a promiseWe must make'Cause the richesWill be plentyWorth the riskAnd chances that we takeThere's a dreamIn the futureThere's a struggleWe have yet to winUse that prideIn our heartsTo lift us upTo tomorrow'Cause just to sit stillWould be a sinAnd lord knowsI knowWhere I've beenOh! When we win,I'll give thanks to my God'Cause I know where I've been.
When people stand up to say “No” to the orthodoxy of the day and society’s prevailing beliefs and attitudes based on the Old Story that threaten and force people to live at a less than their fullest, then healing of the society begins.
When the rest of the Canada begins to hear the pleas for dignity from Aboriginal Peoples and participate in the healing journey for all Canadians, the healing in Canada will begin.
When society begins to realise that the healing of the entire society depends on the healing of the wounded and marginalised, then healing has begun.
When we, as a faith community, do not participate in this healing process, we are diminished, stunted, living with our heads down so we cannot see our brothers and sisters. Becoming an intercultural church is about affirming life for all so that all can live to their fullest in the New Story.
Luke recorded the day when Jesus not only sought out the bent woman but also touched her and healed her on the Sabbath. It is not the dogma of the religion that healed the bent woman. It is the homeless rabbi named Jesus from Nazareth who healed and enabled the bent women to stretch to her fullest.
The story does not end after her healing. The healing also comes to the community. Jan Richardson, a Methodist pastor, writes in her book, Sacred Journey: A Woman’s Book of Daily Prayer.
“The community also receives Jesus’ freeing touch as it begins to learn about the care God calls us to have for one another. With Jesus’ touch of the woman’s body, with her song of praise, and with the community’s rejoicing, this story challenges us to consider how we participate in the diminishment of those around us and how we must provide the condition of healing – physical, emotional, economic, relational – to happen for us all.”[iv]
In a place where people lives were bent with the burdens of the Old Story Jesus started the New Story that “un-bent” and stretched everyone to their fullest potential. For us, intercultural ministry is the New Story of Jesus Christ for our church. It is the story of interconnectedness, interdependence, and intercultural relationship amongst all God’s people.
The bent woman got un-bent and she was able to celebrate with her community and praise God for the gift.
What about us? in the here and now?
What parts of our lives are not living to the fullest? Who are we in the face of those who live at less than the fullest?
Jesus continues to challenge us to seek out those who are prevented from living to their fullest, and to heal them. Jesus continues to seek us out and heal us when we are bent and stunted by the prejudices and unwillingness of others to see us the way God sees us. For we, too, need healing. For we know where we’ve been. And we know we are going on a journey of healing and freedom for all God’s children.
May our life be abundant with creative ways of stretching to our fullest.
Amen.
----
[i] Katherine Barber, The Canadian Oxford Dictionary, (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1998 ed.) 1027.
[ii] Bill Phipps, Cause for Hope: Humanity at the Crossroads, (Kelowna: CopperHouse, 2007) 71-109.
[iii] James Cone, A Black Theology of Liberation, (Maryknoll: Orbis Books, 1986) 203.
[iv] Jan L. Richardson, Sacred Journeys: A Woman’s Book of Daily Prayer, (Nashville: Upper Room Books, 1996) 414.